Back in her noughties heyday, Welsh singing sensation Duffy conquered the world. Known for her 2008 monster hit Mercy, the musician who found fame on Wales’ equivalent of The X Factor quickly bagged a Grammy, three Brit Awards and a prestigious Ivor Novello prize as fans went crazy for her amazing voice, beautiful songs and bombshell looks.
But while Duffy became incredibly famous overnight, not to mention insanely wealthy, just a few years later she mysteriously disappeared from the spotlight altogether. It’s true to say the singer’s second album Endlessly, a follow up to the 9-million selling debut Rockferry, proved something of a flop but a much darker and devastating reason would later emerge for Duffy’s exodus from fame.
In 2020, the courageous star described being raped, drugged and kidnapped on her birthday in an ordeal that saw her flown to another country and left in fear for her life. In an open letter titled The 5th House, Duffy said: “It was my birthday, I was drugged at a restaurant, I was drugged then for four weeks and travelled to a foreign country.
“I can’t remember getting on the plane and came round in the back of a travelling vehicle. I was put into a hotel room, and the perpetrator returned and raped me. I remember the pain and trying to stay conscious in the room after it happened. I flew back with him, I stayed calm and as normal as someone could in a situation like that, and when I got home, I sat, dazed, like a zombie. I knew my life was in immediate danger, he made veiled confessions of wanting to kill me.
“The perpetrator drugged me in my own home in the four weeks… It didn’t feel safe to go to the police. I felt if anything went wrong, I would be dead, and he would have killed me. I could not risk being mishandled or it being all over the news during my danger. I really had to follow what instincts I had. I have told two female police officers, during different threatening incidents in the past decade, it is on record.”
The star was praised by national charity Rape Crisis for speaking out about being a victim of sexual assault. “In speaking out Duffy is reaching out to those people who maybe are suffering on their own,” they said.
Now, Duffy has been seen for the first time in years in a TikTok clip by dance artist E.motion, who excitedly teased a remix of her classic track Mercy. In a rare glimpse of the star Duffy, now 40, is seen miming to the track’s famous lyrics and confidently winking into the camera. She is also pictured helping to mix the track in the studio, with E.motion revealing it was the legendary singer who contacted them about the upcoming collab.
Fans were thrilled with the news, with one saying: “Duffy, you were, are and always will be SENSATIONAL. Welcome back” and another adding: “One of my favourite singers ever”. But what do celebrity PR experts think about the possibility of a successful Duffy comeback after so much time has passed?
“Duffy’s story is definitely unique and I think that actually works in her favour,” ‘PR to the stars’ Mayah Riaz, from mayah.media, told The Mirror. “There’s still a sense of mystery and unfinished business around her career. Fans definitely remember her fondly, and nostalgia is a powerful tool in music.”
“If this is just a way for Duffy to ease back into public consciousness, then I think it’s a smart and a low-pressure move,” Mayah added. “Posting a TikTok teaser rather than a big PR push or interview is a subtle way to reintroduce herself. It almost feels like she is testing the waters, perhaps gauging interest without committing to a full comeback just yet.
Noting a potential hidden message in the song choice, Mayah said: “The choice of lyrics she has chosen does carry a certain weight given what she went through. Whether it is intentional or not, it makes people feel something, and that’s actually powerful when it comes to a comeback.”
The crisis management expert said if Duffy wanted to relaunch her career rather than provide fans with a nostalgic refresh of her best-known track, an ‘intentional and strategic’ approach was needed. “Her situation is unlike a typical pop star returning after a hiatus, as she stepped away due to deeply personal trauma,” she said. “Meaning it’s crucial her comeback is handled with care, authenticity, and involve a right balance of storytelling and music.
“Duffy’s story is powerful and there’s already curiosity around her return. However, she needs to control how she shares it. A carefully chosen exclusive interview would allow her to tell her story in a way that feels safe and empowering. This doesn’t have to be a tell-all, but fans will want to hear why she’s returning and what music means to her now.
“Instead of jumping straight into festival slots or TV performances, I would advise her that it would better to do a series of intimate, invite-only gigs. These would let her reintroduce herself in a comfortable, controlled environment where her artistry does the talking, not the hype.”
Brought up in the tiny town of Nefyn, North Wales, Duffy’s childhood was tough, with the star living in a safe house for a spell as a teenager when her stepfather’s first wife offered an acquaintance £3,000 to kill him. The singer once described how she went off the rails as a teenager, telling the Daily Mail: “From 15 to 18, I did everything — body-piercing to going on 48-hour binge beach parties, to stealing someone’s boat at night and rowing it from one place to another when we were drunk, to jumping on a milk float for a lift home”.
By her mid 20s, Duffy was a star thanks to her incredible voice. “Motown with a modern stomp, blasted out of every car stereo, gym playlist and mediocre wedding DJ set for about 18 months straight,” said media expert Mark Borkowski (borkowski.co.uk), describing the singer’s huge 2008 hit Mercy. “It was so big it started to feel like it had always existed. She won the BRITs, snagged a Grammy, became the face of Diet Coke and then… vanished. One minute, top of the charts. Next, mythologised in whispers.
“Years later, came the brutal truth: Duffy hadn’t just disappeared. She’d been abducted, drugged, raped. A horror story almost too grotesque to absorb. Suddenly, that disappearance wasn’t enigmatic, it was tragic. Not artistic mystery — survival. Her silence? Deafening in hindsight.”
The star’s rapist has never been publicly named and in her brave online essay about her ordeal, she said she became suicidal before a psychologist specialising in trauma and sexual violence came to her aid and her slow recovery began. “I owe it to myself to release a body of work someday, though I very much doubt I will ever be the person people once knew,” the singer wrote in conclusion. “My music will be measured on the merit of its quality and this story will be something I experienced and not something that describes me.”
Mark also notes the poignant decision to tease a remix of Mercy. He said: “The lyric — ‘You got me begging you for mercy’ — no longer reads as sassy retro hit. It echoes trauma, pain, and survival. Intentional or not, it’s either an act of lyrical reclamation or a deeply uncomfortable coincidence, depending entirely on who’s pulling the strings behind the edit.”
Whether Duffy has decided the time is right for this new body of work remains to be seen but what is clear is fans around the country are willing to welcome the star back with open arms. “Given her story, people will root for her but I would stress upon her to make sure she’s ready, both personally and professionally,” said Mayah. “The industry has changed a lot in her absence.
“Sure, there’s always room for raw talent and emotional honesty. I would advise her to lean into that, rather than just nostalgia. I’m excited to see how she could make a truly meaningful comeback.”
At Reach and across our entities we and our partners use information collected through cookies and other identifiers from your device to improve experience on our site, analyse how it is used and to show personalised advertising. You can opt out of the sale or sharing of your data, at any time clicking the “Do Not Sell or Share my Data” button at the bottom of the webpage. Please note that your preferences are browser specific. Use of our website and any of our services represents your acceptance of the use of cookies and consent to the practices described in our Privacy Notice and Cookie Notice.