Both federal and provincial governments have invested billions into the swift expansion of the electric vehicle sector. However, significant projects related to EVs and batteries in Ontario, Quebec, and British Columbia have been postponed, terminated, halted, or significantly altered. In one instance, a company has even filed for bankruptcy as automakers and suppliers adapt to demand that has been lower than expected.
The most recent delay involves Volkswagen’s extensive PowerCo battery facility in St. Thomas, Ontario, where the timeline for production has been pushed back by two years to 2029 due to “changing market demand.”
These delays have sparked concerns about whether Canada overestimated the speed at which the EV market would develop. Some critics suggest that demand may never achieve the levels necessary to sustain the scale of battery production that governments aimed to attract, while others maintain that these challenges represent momentary interruptions in the long-term transition to electrification.
One million batteries, but for what purpose?
Grieg Mordue, a former executive at Toyota and retired professor from McMaster University who examined the automotive industry, argues that the St. Thomas facility highlights two significant issues with Canada’s EV investment approach: scale and location.
Upon the project’s announcement in 2023, PowerCo indicated that the facility would eventually produce enough battery cells for approximately one million EVs annually.
Mordue points out that this seems inefficient since Volkswagen’s principal assembly operations are situated in the southern United States and Mexico, which means that batteries manufactured in St. Thomas would face long transportation distances to reach their intended vehicles.

A person handles an electric vehicle battery on display at the EV & Charging Expo in Toronto. Ottawa and the provinces have committed billions of dollars in public support to attract EV and battery manufacturing. (Oksana Shtohryn/CBC)
He further explains that Europe doesn’t seem to be a viable market either, as Volkswagen (VW) already possesses battery production capabilities there.
Even when combined, Volkswagen’s North American factories do not produce an adequate number of vehicles to create a substantial demand for a million batteries annually.
“They have a million batteries,” he remarked. “What are they going to do with them?”
Neither VW nor its PowerCo division responded to a request for comment.

Ontario Premier Doug Ford speaks at a news conference announcing the St. Thomas plant in 2023. (Kate Dubinski/CBC)
VW has stated that the plant continues to be a key element of its North American battery strategy and that construction is ongoing despite the delay in production.
The company also mentioned that the postponement will enable it to integrate newer battery technologies and scale production in line with demand as it evolves.
Mordue noted that this could ultimately be beneficial for taxpayers, resulting in a reduced subsidy bill.
Much of the financial support pledged to Volkswagen is still dependent on the volume of batteries produced at the plant. With the production timeline now set for 2029, and incentives expected to decline starting in 2030 and concluding in 2032, Mordue predicts that governments will likely incur “a whole lot less” than the original maximum amount.
Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada confirmed in a statement that the federal government has so far allocated $700 million towards the construction of the St. Thomas battery facility, indicating that Ontario is accountable for one-third of the $13.2 billion in production subsidies agreed upon by the governments.
“The government remains engaged with PowerCo regarding their revised timelines,” the statement added.
Ontario’s Ministry of Economic Development, Job Creation and Trade did not provide a response by the deadline.
A long-term gamble
Nonetheless, others contend that assessing current EV demand overlooks the long-term perspective on which investments like St. Thomas were made.

A sign marks the entrance to General Motors’ CAMI Assembly plant in Ingersoll, Ont. The plant was converted into Canada’s first full-scale EV plant in 2022, but production was suspended in 2025. (Denis Babin/CBC/Radio-Canada)
“These investments are intended to endure for 50 to 70 years or more,” stated Joanna Kyriazis, director of policy and strategy at Clean Energy Canada, in an interview with CBC News.
She emphasized that the present slowdown should be viewed as growing pains in an industry still in transition, rather than as evidence that Canada has overbuilt battery capacity.
Signs indicate that Canada’s EV market might already be on the mend following a slowdown.
Statistics Canada reports that new registrations for battery-only EVs surged by 37.4 percent in the second quarter of 2026 compared to the same period last year. When hybrids are included, Canadians registered a total of 58,811 new zero-emission vehicles during this quarter, reflecting a 26.7 percent increase.
Kyriazis asserts that the investments aim to ensure Canada remains a relevant player as the global automotive industry transitions away from gasoline-powered vehicles.

An electric vehicle’s charging port is displayed at the 2026 Canadian International AutoShow in Toronto. Despite government subsidies for producers and consumers, electric vehicles accounted for 11.7 per cent of new light-duty vehicle sales in Canada in the first three months of 2026. (Michael Charles Cole/CBC)
“It’s not just about maintaining a position in the North American auto industry. It’s about whether Canada will have an automotive sector that can thrive in the 21st century,” she stated.
“There’s a clear trajectory for the global auto market, and if Canada wants to sustain a competitive automotive industry going forward, we must be able to manufacture and sell competitively priced electric vehicles and their components.”
Kyriazis also mentions that the potential market for these batteries extends beyond electric vehicles. As electricity grids evolve, the need for batteries to store energy and aid in balancing supply and demand will only increase.
-
Gas prices and new incentives sparking more EV sales
-
Gas prices are dropping. You can thank the ‘winter blend’ for that
She noted that both the St. Thomas facility and a NextStar plant in Windsor were initially designed with a short-term strategy of producing batteries suitable for grid-scale storage while the adoption of EVs in North America stabilized.
Kyriazis contends that the current U.S. withdrawal from electric vehicles might be a temporary phase and that Canada should not base its long-term industrial strategy on policies that could shift with future administrations.
Evidence suggests that the push for EV battery production may have been premature rather than fundamentally misguided. The broader rationale for establishing domestic battery manufacturing capabilities remains intact.
According to the International Energy Agency, China produced over 80 percent of the world’s battery cells last year, prompting North American and European governments to develop domestic supply chains in an industry that is still heavily reliant on Asia.
Will consumers catch up?
Ross McKitrick, an economics professor at the University of Guelph, is less optimistic that time will resolve the issue. He acknowledges that EVs have an established market but argues that governments based their policies on expectations of demand that far exceed what has materialized thus far.
“What the government has been trying to do is artificially create that market,” he stated. “The numbers simply don’t add up.”
McKitrick highlights the billions allocated by governments to manufacturers for the production of EVs and batteries, while also providing incentives for consumers to purchase these vehicles, as evidence that the industry has not been able to sustain itself at the scale envisioned by the government.
In a 2024 paper published in the Canadian Journal of Economics, McKitrick cautioned that if the sales targets for EVs in Canada rise faster than actual consumer demand, it could negatively impact automakers and the broader economy.
-
What on Earth
Want to buy a used EV? Here’s what to look out for
-
What on Earth
As more EVs hit the road, will we have the mechanics to keep them running?
In 2026, Ottawa eliminated EV sales mandates and is in the process of repealing the broader federal regulations. It unveiled replacement emissions standards in February, with consultations for proposed regulations continuing until October 29.
Despite years of governmental incentives aimed at promoting consumer purchases, electric vehicles still represent a small fraction of new car sales in Canada.
In the first quarter of 2026, electric vehicles accounted for 11.7 percent of new light-duty vehicle sales in Canada, according to Transport Canada, down from a peak of 15.4 percent in 2024.
“At this stage, it’s a niche market,” McKitrick observed. “Some households appreciate the product and are willing to pay for it.”
